Article 5 of the Indian Constitution

Article 5 of the Indian Constitution

Article 5 of the Indian Constitution deals with citizenship at the commencement of the Constitution. It lays down the criteria for determining who would be considered a citizen of India when the Constitution came into force on January 26, 1950. Since India became independent from British rule on August 15, 1947, the need to define Indian citizenship was crucial, especially in the context of the partition of India and the large-scale migration that followed.

Article 5 provides a broad and inclusive definition of Indian citizenship for those who were already residing in India at the time of independence. It ensures that people who had a strong connection with India—either by birth, descent, or residence—would be recognized as citizens of the newly formed Republic of India.

---

Text of Article 5

"At the commencement of this Constitution, every person who has his domicile in the territory of India and –
(a) who was born in the territory of India; or
(b) either of whose parents was born in the territory of India; or
(c) who has been ordinarily resident in the territory of India for not less than five years immediately preceding such commencement, shall be a citizen of India."

---

Key Features of Article 5

1. Effective Date – Article 5 came into force on 26th January 1950, the day the Indian Constitution was adopted and India became a Republic.

2. Single Point in Time – It defines citizenship only at the commencement of the Constitution, meaning it does not deal with citizenship acquired later.

3. Three Main Criteria – Citizenship under Article 5 is based on:

   • Birth in India

   • Descent from Indian parents

   • Domicile in India

4. Inclusive Approach – It recognized not only people born in India but also those born abroad to Indian parents, as long as they met the domicile requirement.

5. Domicile Requirement – Having a permanent home in India or an intention to reside permanently was essential for citizenship under this Article.

6. Applies to Natural Persons Only – Article 5 grants citizenship to individuals, not to legal entities like companies or associations.

7. Part of a Larger Framework – It works alongside Articles 6 to 11, which deal with citizenship for people migrating from Pakistan, voluntary acquisition of citizenship, and the power of Parliament to make citizenship laws.

8. Historical Relevance – It was crucial during the immediate post-independence period when defining the first citizens of India was a national priority.

---

Importance of Article 5 in Defining Indian Citizenship

Article 5 holds a special place in the Indian Constitution as it laid the foundation for determining the citizenship of independent India on the day the Constitution came into force, i.e., 26th January 1950. At a time when the country had just gained independence and undergone the trauma of partition, there was an urgent need to define who could be recognized as an Indian citizen. Article 5 fulfilled this purpose by establishing clear criteria based on birth, descent, and domicile.

The significance of Article 5 also lies in its role in maintaining stability and unity during a politically sensitive period. By recognizing individuals with strong connections to India—whether by birth or permanent residence—it ensured that those who had historically and culturally belonged to the country could claim citizenship without unnecessary legal hurdles. This was particularly important for people who were displaced during partition but chose to remain in India.

Furthermore, Article 5 acted as a bridge between the colonial past and independent governance. It replaced the British-era laws on nationality with an indigenous constitutional provision, symbolizing India’s sovereignty in deciding who belonged to the nation. It also laid the groundwork for future citizenship laws, such as the Citizenship Act, 1955, which continues to govern citizenship matters today.

In essence, Article 5 was not just a legal provision—it was a statement of identity and belonging for millions of people at the dawn of independent India. By setting the first constitutional definition of Indian citizenship, it helped shape the demographic and political character of the nation for generations to come.

---

Comparison of Article 5 with Other Citizenship Provisions

Key Focus of Citizenship Articles in the Indian Constitution

1. Article 5 – Defines citizenship at the commencement of the Constitution for those residing in India.
2. Article 6 – Grants citizenship to migrants from Pakistan who moved to India before July 19, 1948.
3. Article 7 – Deals with people who migrated to Pakistan but later returned to India.
4. Article 8 – Provides citizenship rights to Indians living abroad.

This structured approach helps in understanding how Article 5 fits within the broader framework of citizenship provisions in the Indian Constitution.

---

Challenges and Implications of Article 5

While Article 5 played a crucial role during the formation of the Indian Constitution, it has faced certain criticisms over time. One major criticism is that it was transitional in nature and became outdated soon after the Constitution came into force. Since it applied only to people who were citizens on 26th January 1950, it did not address future issues related to migration, refugees, or foreign nationals seeking citizenship. This meant that for later cases, Parliament had to pass separate laws like the Citizenship Act, 1955 to fill the gaps.

Another criticism is that Article 5 did not fully resolve the complex problem of partition-related migration. Although it tried to include people born in India or with strong ties to India, there were many grey areas, especially for those who moved between India and Pakistan multiple times before and after independence. This created confusion and legal disputes, particularly in border states like Punjab and West Bengal.

Some critics also argue that Article 5, combined with Articles 6 and 7, created overlapping and sometimes contradictory rules. For example, while Article 5 included certain people as citizens, Article 7 excluded those who migrated to Pakistan unless they met special conditions. This overlapping framework led to court cases and uncertainty for many people about their citizenship status.

Lastly, Article 5 did not address issues of dual citizenship or the rights of overseas Indians, which became relevant later as many Indians migrated abroad for work or education. These gaps highlighted the need for further constitutional and legislative measures to deal with citizenship in a modern, globalized context.

---

Conclusion

Article 5 of the Indian Constitution played a crucial role in defining who would be an Indian citizen at the time of independence. It provided an inclusive framework by granting citizenship to individuals who were born in India, had Indian-born parents, or had been residents for at least five years. The provision ensured a smooth transition for people living in India and established the foundation for future citizenship laws.

Although Article 5 is no longer directly applicable today, as citizenship matters are now governed by the Citizenship Act, 1955, its significance remains high. It laid the groundwork for India’s citizenship policies and continues to influence legal interpretations of citizenship rights.